The Mind That Needs Both Order and Chaos
AuDHD, and what the push-pull of order and novelty teaches us about everyday friction.
Most writing about daily friction assumes the friction comes from outside: the inbox, the commute, the interruption. But some of it comes from inside, from two needs that will not sit still together. What happens to a day when you require order and crave chaos in equal measure, and neither one will yield?
Sarah Hendrickx describes living with both autism and ADHD, a combination increasingly called AuDHD, as needing order and routine just as much as she craves excitement and variety [3]. Put that way it sounds like a contradiction, and in a sense it is. One disposition builds walls around the day to keep it predictable. The other keeps looking for a gap in the wall to climb through. The friction is not between the person and the world. It is between two systems inside the same head, each with a legitimate claim.
This is worth sitting with, because the usual model of micro-stress is additive and external. Small frictions land one after another, they stack, and eventually the total tips you over. That model is useful, but it misses a whole category of drain: the stress of self-negotiation. When part of you has planned the afternoon down to the half hour and another part is already bored by the plan, the cost is paid before anything external goes wrong. You spend energy managing yourself, and that energy does not show up on any to-do list.
Hendrickx's account matters precisely because it is testimony rather than a trial. She is not reporting an effect size. She is describing the texture of a life where the methodical and the mercurial coexist, where routine is not a cage but a form of relief, and where variety is not indulgence but a need [3]. The honest reading is that this is one person's experience, generalised cautiously. But it illuminates something the rest of us feel in smaller doses. Most people carry some version of this tension. We want the security of a settled routine and we resent it the moment we have it. We crave novelty and then find it exhausting.
The practical lesson is not to pick a side. It is to stop treating the oscillation as a failure of discipline. If you build a day that is all structure, the part of you that needs stimulation will sabotage it, usually through procrastination that looks like laziness but is closer to starvation. If you build a day that is all spontaneity, the part that needs predictability will flood you with low-grade anxiety. The friction is minimised not by eliminating one need but by designing for both: fixed scaffolding with deliberately unscheduled space inside it.
There is a wider point here about how we name stress. The clinical literature tends to locate stress in environments and events, and for good reason, because those are measurable and sometimes changeable. Chronic stress is linked to a cascade of physical pathways, from dysregulation of the HPA axis to inflammation and endothelial dysfunction [5]. But the lived experience of daily friction often starts earlier and smaller, in the mismatch between how you are built and how your day is shaped. You cannot defuse a stressor you have misdiagnosed. Calling internal conflict a willpower problem guarantees you will keep trying the wrong fix.
What Hendrickx offers, without framing it as advice, is a kind of permission. The goal is not a frictionless self. It is a self whose competing needs are both allowed to make their case, and a day with enough give in it to let them take turns [3]. That is a more forgiving target than the usual demand to simply be more consistent. Consistency, for many people, is the thing quietly wearing them down.
RESEARCH RADAR
- Welcome to the mixed-up, joyful world of AuDHD (Aeon) [3]: A first-person essay on living with both autism and ADHD, describing a simultaneous need for order and craving for variety. It reframes certain forms of daily friction as internal negotiation rather than external overload.
- Biomolecular pathways from chronic stress to cardiovascular dysfunction (Biomolecules) [5]: This review argues preoperative chronic stress is a plausibly modifiable surgical risk, acting through HPA axis dysregulation, sympathetic activation, inflammation and hypercoagulability. It notes risk models do not yet incorporate psychosocial stress despite over 300 million noncardiac surgeries performed annually.
- Beyond burnout in correctional officers (Frontiers in Public Health) [6]: Researchers synthesise how organisational strain, shift work and restricted autonomy drive not just psychological harm but sleep disruption, cardiometabolic and musculoskeletal risk. The value is in treating these as one connected pathway rather than separate problems.
ONE THING TO TRY
Look at tomorrow and find one block you have fully planned. Leave a genuinely empty slot next to it, half an hour with no assigned task. Treat that emptiness as part of the structure, not a gap in it. See whether the planned block feels lighter for having room beside it.
WORTH YOUR ATTENTION
- Welcome to the mixed-up, joyful world of AuDHD (Aeon) [3]: A warm, precise account of two dispositions sharing one mind, and why that need not be a contradiction to resolve.
- Why astrophysics needs to abandon the big questions (Aeon) [1]: A case for attending to the cosmos in its glorious messiness, a useful antidote to the urge to tidy everything.
- In tiny biospheres, an artist reflects our own fragility (Aeon) [4]: Self-contained miniature worlds as living metaphors for a fragile, finely balanced system.
- Meet the invisible workers who teach self-driving cars to see (Aeon) [2]: On the low-paid labour in Kenya, the Philippines and Venezuela underwriting the automated future elsewhere.
We opened with a question about the day that holds two incompatible needs. The answer is not to make the needs behave. It is to stop reading their push and pull as a fault. A life that wants both order and chaos, in Hendrickx's telling, is not broken. It is simply full, and it asks for a shape roomy enough to hold both [3].
Sources
- [1] Celestial nuisance: Aeon
- [2] Their eyes: Aeon
- [3] Methodical/mercurial: Aeon
- [4] Like aliens: Aeon
- [5] Biomolecular Pathways Linking Preoperative Chronic Stress to Postoperative Cardiovascular Dysfunction in Noncardiac Surgery: Biomolecules
- [6] Beyond burnout: occupational risk pathways linking stress, sleep, and multisystem morbidity in correctional officers: Frontiers in public health